Oh dear...

Oh dear...

Favorite Post Q4

My favorite post from quarter three is my post entitled "Gross
National Happiness."

I think that this post did a successful job of combining succinct descriptions of unknown terms with links to more elaborate descriptions. I also think that I did a good job of mixing my own theories with those of the hosts of "Stuff You Should Know."

Wednesday, October 14, 2009

The Face of Evil


   For Jewish confirmation class (much the same as a Christian confirmation) we read a book called The Sunflower.  This “true” story takes place in the middle of WWII and the author, Simon Wiesenthal, is a Jew in a concentration camp in Poland.  He is approached by a nurse.  The nurse brings him to a Nazi guard who wishes to apologize.  I’m not going to say what happened as the book is a really great 98 page read.
   As we talked through the complexities of the story, I found that I was the only one who would forgive the Nazi.  I couldn’t help but notice that, almost every story of the holocaust painted Nazis as monsters and Jews as helpless creatures.  I have no argument that the Jews were helpless creatures, the atrocities committed on them were horrible.  Bare with me, I believe a large number of The Nazis were equally as helpless.
   I couldn’t help but think that 95% of the people I was discussing this book would have joined the Nazi party had they been in the same position as the now expiring Nazi guard.  I know it seems taboo and terribly disrespectful to all the people who were brutally slaughtered, but I feel terrible for all the helpless children who were talked into the Holocaust.

   Before you judge me or my views, take a look at the sociological implications and basis for my response to the book, maybe look at the famous Zimbardo Prison Experiment in a Stanford University basement, pictured to the left.

1 comment:

  1. Sam,

    Nice job here and throughout the blog. You are certainly bold in your claims, yet this one is tempered with examples from The Sunflower and Zimbardo. Keep being daring.

    Let's talk about the face of evil sometime (it's a fav. topic of mine). It was a common expression in the Bush White House.

    Overall,
    good job!

    ReplyDelete